Farmer Wants a Wife Season 3 Episode 4: Drama, Decisions, and Dancing
In this episode of Farmer Wants a Wife, titled “You Can’t Pick All 5,” emotions run high as farmers and potential partners make pivotal decisions in their search for love. The episode features intense conversations about plans, unexpected confrontations, and a surprise trip to Tennessee that changes everything.
Tensions rise on Matt’s farm, especially for Jay, who must choose between his heart and head. As John navigates his feelings for Samantha, country music stars Brad Paisley and Kimberly Williams-Paisley offer some home truths.
This episode marks a significant turning point, with some contestants leaving while others deepen their connections through honest discussions. This sets the stage for the rest of the season.
Jay Faces A Hard Decision Between Julia And Viviane-Lee
We start the episode with Jay trying to choose between Julia and Viviane-Lee. His primary concern about Julia is whether she wants farm life long-term. Julia addresses his fears during their conversation. She says she loves the peaceful farm lifestyle and has met only real people there.
“I want to get married and have children someday, so this environment suits me perfectly,” Julia says. Jay moves on to Viviane-Lee. He worries that she isn’t ready to settle down, and that’s because she has never settled down. Despite their sweet connection, Jay confesses something is lacking.
“There’s a spark that just isn’t there between us,” Jay tells her bluntly. Julia gets emotional when she finds out that Jay opted to send Viviane-Lee home. Fingers crossed, she said, “because everything happens for a reason.” This is Jay’s first significant vote as he refines his search for a life partner compatible with a farming lifestyle.
Jay even spends some time with T’yana while loading hay later on. He likes her energy and perspective, while Karina fears she is squandering her opportunity to bond with him. The dynamics on the farm shift as each woman struggles to find her place in Jay’s heart and on his land.
Disharmony On Matt’s Farm
Matt’s farm becomes a drama when Halleh disappears in the early hours of the morning. The other women get suspicious immediately, questioning whether she slipped out to spend time alone with Matt. And this makes for a tense mood on the farm.
Despite Jordyn’s hope that the possibility isn’t genuine and the doubts this voiceover makes Rachel confront, she waits with mistrust as we, the audience, learn that whatever is happening is happening. The mystery deepens until Halleh reveals she was journaling as she watched the sunrise.
Matt attempts to clarify things with the women, but Rachel doubts him. “I need to know—something’s not clicking,” she says when she hopes for straight answers from Matt. This disagreement sows seeds of doubt that bloom throughout the episode.
Later, as all the farmers and women come together in Tennessee, Matt pulls his group aside for a private conversation. He insists they must trust him and says he wasn’t with Halleh that morning. Halleh says she feels hurt by their assumptions about her and no longer cares if they ever want to befriend her.
Some women accept this, but Rachel is still not convinced. According to Matt, Rachel could have had some trust issues that made it challenging for her to believe him. Things come to a head during a later scene when Rachel announces that she feels she can’t remain on the farm, having told Matt she sees no future there.
Matt admits to being hurt by her abrupt departure. “Dating multiple women is hard,” Matt admits, saying he wants a partner who becomes “fully now that there’s potentially someone who could become my wife.”
Everything Changes When The Surprise Trip to Tennessee
In a plot twist, Colton reveals that everyone will head to Tennessee for a night of dancing. The excitement and energy on the farms are palpable as the news spreads that all the farmers and women will be together in one location. It’s the first time every contestant will meet, which opens up new dynamics.
When millers arrive at the Tennessee barn, farmers also catch up with one another as women share their experiences. A special guest joins host Kimberly Williams-Paisley—her husband, country music star Brad Paisley. The hip couple gives advice based on their own city girl-country boy romance.
Brad does not mince words, telling Matt point blank, “You can’t keep all five of them around and keep leading them on.” If you get nervous around someone, they’re probably “the one,” he advises the farmers “to pay attention.” Kimberly springs another surprise on the evening with a visit from “Farmer Wants a Wife” Season 2 couple Mitchell and Sydney.
Mitchell tells anyone feeling hesitant to “just follow your heart,” while Sydney says to “open up and have conversations about whatever might be on your mind.” Kimberly reveals that, by the end of the night, each farmer must decide who from their group will go next on a solo date. And this makes even a touch at the barn dance matter.
Office Confrontations Take Emotional Turns That Lead To Surprising Decisions
The gathering in Tennessee serves as a Petri dish for confrontations and emotional revelations. T’yana and the other women have little in common, and she says that Sydney encourages her to talk to them.
When she asks why she feels lousy energy from them, Grace calls her out on a comment from earlier. “You said that none of us would get to the finals,” Grace points out. “It felt like I was in a game.
(That was mean, Julia adds; T’yana once called her a mean name.) (T’yana “apologizes within seconds,” but Julia observes that T’yana dominates dinner conversations while the two others sit by.) The line of talk overwhelms Grace, who gets teary-eyed and worried that T’yana will tell Jay she’s a “mean girl.”
Meanwhile, Samantha sees John tangoing with Lily and declares she “is never going to chase someone.” Later, she tells Halleh that she wants to go home. “I love many things about John, but I am not feeling aligned,” she explains. Halleh tells her to make sure she doesn’t regret her decision.
Samantha is conflicted, admitting, “Whatever is meant to be will happen no matter what,” but she realizes she has to talk to John before making her ultimate decision. If she leaves, John could have a different journey on the show.
Open Honest Communication Builds Stronger Relationships
Despite the drama, some relationships become stronger as they have honest conversations. Grace looks to Jay for reassurance following her blowup with T’yana. They leave the dance floor for a private chat, during which Grace says that T’yana made an “offensive comment” after their first date.
When she says the date was close to her, Jay quickly cuddles her, saying, “Don’t let those words get to your head because that date was special to me.” He says, “No one else can determine how I feel,” and lightens the mood with a joke. The end of their talk is capped with a kiss, deepening their bond.
Matt and Jordyn seem to hit it off even more as they continue into the night, hinting at their possible future. Bailee and Colton sneak in for a passionate kiss during the dance, which angers Hope and shows how quickly new relationships are in place — and ripped apart.
John struggles internally with his feelings toward Samantha, admitting to the other farmers that “she’s different because, unlike the other girls, she’s not trying to win me over.” Thanks to the honest talks throughout the evening and a new date card that helps clear the air and creates space for future episodes.
FAQ
Q: Why did Jay pick Julia over Viviane-Lee?
A: Jay said that although he had good chemistry with Viviane-Lee, there was a “spark missing” between the two. He also worried about her readiness to settle down because she had never had a long-term relationship. Julia, for her part, assured him that she very much enjoyed farm life and wanted to marry and have children in that one.)
Q: What was the source of the tension on Matt’s farm?
A: One morning, Halleh went missing, and the other women suspected she was secretly meeting Matt, creating tension. Although Halleh explained she was journaling while watching the sunrise, Rachel was skeptical, prompting her to leave the show.
Q: Who is Brad Paisley, and why was he on the show?
A: Brad Paisley, a country music star and the husband of the show’s host, Kimberly Williams-Paisley. They jointly appeared to dispense advice to the farmers from a city girl – heart of gold – meets country boy perspective, having had this success themselves.
Q: What prompted Rachel to leave Matt’s farm?
A: Rachel has gone because she could not resolve her trust issues about Matt and Halleh. A few days later, after being skeptical of Matt’s explanation for Halleh’s early morning absence, Rachel said she no longer imagined living on the farm.
Q: Is Samantha leaving John’s farm?
A: By the end of the episode, Samantha was thinking about leaving because she and John were not “on the same page” despite Samantha loving so much about him. She also intended to consult John before she reached her final decision.
Final Words
And what luck that it’s Episode 4 of the 3rd Season of Farmer Wants a Wife! So now the farmers must reckon that they “can’t pick all five” women and are left to make tough decisions about potential romantic connections. Eager for fun and dancing, the surprise trip to Tennessee brought clarity through confrontation and honest conversations.
As Rachel and perhaps Samantha decide to walk away of their own accord, we see that falling in love does not just lie in the farmers’ hands, but also in the women’s — and the women deciding whether living on a farm is right for them. Brad Paisley’s suggestion that the farmers listen to their instincts when they get a weird vibe from someone could be helpful as the season continues.
The emotional breakthroughs in this episode are a foundation for deeper connections in the coming weeks. With fewer women on each farm, the remaining relationships will inevitably intensify as everyone closes in to discover their perfect partner. For viewers who’ve bought into such rural love stories, the journey is only beginning to get interesting—heartbreak and happiness are no doubt waiting down the country road.
Table of Contents